Best Mascara for Sensitive Eyes: My 4 Go-Tos and 6 More to Try

Kosas Soulgazer, ILIA Limitless Lash and Merit Clean Lash in Brown, the best mascaras for sensitive eyes

Most mascaras set my eyes off. Not a little bit, either.

I have ocular rosacea (plus blepharitis and the rest of the gang that comes with it), and my lashes are pretty wrecked because of it. There are four mascaras my eyes handle without any irritation, two of them from Merit, and they’re the first four below. None of them leave me with panda eyes or turn taking them off at night into a fight.

Four isn’t much of a list though, is it? So I’ve added six more that keep coming up for sensitive eyes, mostly tubing formulas that come off with warm water, plus a cheaper Boots one and a US drugstore one. For those six I’ve stuck to what the brands and shops say about them, so you know what’s in the tube and how it comes off before you spend anything.

At a glance

The four mascaras I wear with ocular rosacea and blepharitis are Kosas Soulgazer, ILIA Limitless Lash, Merit Clean Lash and Merit Clean Volume. Six more listed for sensitive eyes: Clinique Lash Power (tubing, ophthalmologist tested), Clinique High Impact, Thrive Causemetics Liquid Lash Extensions (tubing, comes off with warm water and a washcloth), No7 Define & Enhance from Boots, Blinc Amplified (tubing) and Almay Thickening, a US drugstore pick. The warm-water kind eye doctors rate is tubing mascara, not fibre mascara. In the UK you’ll find them at Space NK, Sephora UK, LOOKFANTASTIC, Boots and Amazon. In the US, try Sephora US, Ulta, Thrive and Amazon.

My codes:

  • LOOKFANTASTIC: LFTFNEVEEN

1. Kosas Soulgazer: the one in my basket every time

Kosas Soulgazer mascara, my pick for sensitive eyes
Kosas Soulgazer mascara
Buy the Kosas Soulgazer mascara hereAt Space NK (ships worldwide, not the US)
More places to buy▾Tap to see where to buy

Kosas Soulgazer is the one that goes in my basket every time. It’s a lengthening mascara with a peptide in it (myristoyl pentapeptide-17, if you like reading labels as much as I do), and Kosas say it gives visibly longer, fuller lashes over six to eight weeks.

Both Space NK and Sephora UK list it as safe for sensitive eyes. The black is called Hypnotize and the brown is Allure, and Space NK has two newer shades on the same page, Enigma and Bewitch.

There’s a travel size at Space NK as well, which is handy if you want to see how your eyes get on with it before buying the full tube.

2. ILIA Limitless Lash: the one that comes off with water

ILIA Limitless Lash Mascara for sensitive eyes
ILIA Limitless Lash Mascara
Buy the ILIA mascara hereAt Space NK (ships worldwide, not the US)
More places to buy▾Tap to see where to buy

ILIA Limitless Lash is my second. The wand has two sides, one that works like a normal brush to lift and a comb side to lengthen and separate, and it comes off with just warm water. That last part matters more than anything when your eyes are already cranky.

Space NK lists it as safe for sensitive eyes, and Sephora UK goes a bit further and calls it ophthalmologist-tested and fine for contact lens wearers. It’s made with beeswax and shea butter. There are two shades – After Midnight, a soft black, and Before Dawn, the rich brown I wear.

3. Merit Clean Lash in Brown: the softer one

Merit Clean Lash Lengthening Mascara in Brown
Merit Clean Lash Lengthening Mascara in Brown
Buy the Merit Clean Lash mascara hereAt Sephora UK
More places to buy▾Tap to see where to buy

US only

Then there’s Merit. I’ve got both of their mascaras in my makeup bag right now, both in brown, and Clean Lash is the lengthening one. Brown mascara is so underrated. It’s softer than black and somehow makes everything look less “done”, which is realy what I’m going for most days anyway.

Because it’s a tubing mascara, it slides off at night with cleanser and warm water instead of me scrubbing at my lids. Merit’s own directions are to comb it through and do a little wiggle at the base of the lashes for thickness. Sephora UK sells it in black and brown.

4. Merit Clean Volume in Brown: the fuller one

Merit Clean Volume tubing mascara in Brown
Merit Clean Volume Mascara in Brown
Buy the Merit Clean Volume mascara hereAt Sephora UK
More places to buy▾Tap to see where to buy

US only

Clean Volume is the other Merit in my bag, also in brown. Where Clean Lash lengthens, this one builds fuller lashes, and the brush is short and small so you can get right into the corners.

It’s tubing too, so it comes off the same way with cleanser and warm water. Merit lists it as ophthalmologist tested and safe for sensitive eyes and contact lenses, and Sephora UK sells it in black and brown.

Those are my four. The next six are ones the brands and shops list for sensitive eyes, and I’ve kept to what they say about each.

5. Clinique Lash Power: the tubing one

Clinique Lash Power tubing mascara for sensitive eyes
Clinique Lash Power Mascara
Buy the Clinique Lash Power mascara hereAt LOOKFANTASTIC (UK)
More places to buy▾Tap to see where to buy

You’ll see Clinique on pretty much every sensitive eyes list, and Lash Power is the one I’d look at first. It’s a tubing formula, so it wraps each lash instead of painting over it, and Clinique says it comes off with warm water.

LOOKFANTASTIC lists it as ophthalmologist tested and fragrance free, and it’s meant to last up to 24 hours without smudging (handy if your eyes water). It comes in Black Onyx and Dark Chocolate.

6. Clinique High Impact: the volume one

Clinique High Impact mascara for sensitive eyes
Clinique High Impact Mascara
Buy the Clinique High Impact mascara hereAt LOOKFANTASTIC (UK)
More places to buy▾Tap to see where to buy

High Impact is Clinique’s volume mascara, so it’s thicker and more dramatic than Lash Power. Clinique sells it as safe for sensitive eyes, and the waterproof version is listed as fine for contact lens wearers too.

One thing to watch for. There’s a High Impact High-Fi version on the same shelf, and that one is fibre-infused, so if you’re avoiding fibres (more on that further down) go for the original.

7. Thrive Causemetics Liquid Lash Extensions: the washcloth one

Thrive Causemetics Liquid Lash Extensions tubing mascara
Thrive Causemetics Liquid Lash Extensions Mascara
Buy the Thrive mascara hereAt Thrive Causemetics (ships to the UK and US)

Thrive’s Liquid Lash Extensions is a tubing mascara, and taking it off is just warm water and a washcloth with a gentle downward sweep, so you don’t need soap or eye makeup remover. Thrive says it’s ophthalmologist tested and allergy tested, and that it won’t flake into your eyes or onto contact lenses.

There are eight shades now, including a few matched to eye colour. Thrive’s own site ships to the UK as well as the US, with free UK delivery over £50.

8. No7 Define & Enhance: the Boots one

No7 Define and Enhance Mascara for sensitive eyes
No7 Define & Enhance Mascara
Buy the No7 mascara hereAt Boots (UK)

If you want a cheaper one you can pick up at Boots, No7 Define & Enhance is it. Boots lists it as suitable for sensitive eyes, and it washes off with warm water.

The cone-shaped brush is made for seperating lashes, and it’s usually under £16.

9. Blinc Amplified: the tubing original

Blinc Amplified tubing mascara
Blinc Amplified Tubing Mascara
Buy the Blinc mascara hereAt Amazon (UK and US)
More places to buy▾Tap to see where to buy

US only

Blinc only makes tubing mascaras, and Amplified is the fuller one. The tubes come off with warm water and a bit of gentle pressure, and LOOKFANTASTIC’s US site lists Blinc as ideal for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.

Amazon has it in the UK, and Ulta has it in the US.

10. Almay Thickening: the drugstore one

Almay Thickening mascara for sensitive eyes
Almay Thickening Mascara
Buy the Almay mascara hereAt Amazon (UK and US)

Almay’s whole range is hypoallergenic and fragrance free, and the Thickening Mascara is listed as ophthalmologist tested and suitable for contact lens wearers. It’s under $10 in most US shops.

You’ll find it easily in the US. Over here it’s an import on Amazon, so check the seller and the price before you buy.

What I check before I buy a mascara for sensitive eyes

After this many stinging mascaras, I check two things now before a new one goes anywhere near my face.

First, how it comes off. I want warm water, or cleanser and warm water, and that’s it. ILIA washes off with water, both Merits are tubing formulas, and the Kosas has never needed a fight either. If a mascara needs an oily remover and a lot of rubbing, it’s a no from me.

Second, whether the shop or the brand lists it for sensitive eyes. No listing is a guarantee, but it’s the quickest way to narrow down a wall of mascaras, and all four of mine have it on at least one listing.

Are fibre mascaras good for sensitive eyes?

I’d heard the mascara that comes off with warm water was the fibre kind. Turns out I had the two mixed up, and the warm-water one is tubing.

Fibre mascaras have tiny fibres mixed in to make lashes look longer, and eye doctors tend to steer sensitive eyes away from them because those fibres can drop into your eyes during the day. Waterproof mascaras get the side-eye too, mostly because getting them off means more rubbing. Tubing is the warm-water kind they do rate, which is why so many on this list are tubing formulas.

Is hypoallergenic mascara better for sensitive eyes?

Hypoallergenic is the word a lot of us search for, so it’s worth knowing that it doesn’t have a set definition. The US FDA says there are no federal standards for using the term on cosmetics, so a brand can print it on the box without passing any particular test.

So I go by how a mascara comes off and what the listing says about sensitive eyes, and less by that one word.

Mascara with ocular rosacea and blepharitis

I have both, and my four are the only mascaras my eyes put up with. Eyes are personal, though, and if yours are flaring right now, your optician or eye doctor is the person to ask before you put anything on your lashes. My eyes are a big part of why I wrote about whether rosacea gets worse with age, if you want the longer story.

If you’re also dealing with rosacea on your face, my Sephora sale picks include the tinted moisturiser and concealer I wear over my redness.

Where to buy all ten

If you’re shopping for someone else, the Kosas Soulgazer set is in my makeup gift sets post, and there are more small bits in my beauty stocking fillers.

FAQs

What is the best mascara for sensitive eyes?

For my eyes it’s Kosas Soulgazer, with ILIA Limitless Lash and Merit’s Clean Lash and Clean Volume close behind. They’re the only four I’ve found that don’t irritate my ocular rosacea and blepharitis. Beyond those, Clinique Lash Power, Thrive Liquid Lash Extensions and Blinc Amplified are tubing mascaras that come off with warm water.

Where can I buy mascara for sensitive eyes in the UK?

Space NK has Kosas Soulgazer and ILIA Limitless Lash, and Sephora UK stocks all four of my picks. Clinique Lash Power and High Impact are at LOOKFANTASTIC, No7 Define & Enhance is at Boots, Blinc is on Amazon, and Thrive ships to the UK from its own site.

Are fibre mascaras good for sensitive eyes?

Eye doctors tend to say to skip them if your eyes are sensitive, because the little fibres can fall into your eyes. Tubing mascaras are the warm-water kind they rate instead.

What is a tubing mascara?

A tubing mascara wraps each lash in tiny polymer tubes. Those slide off with warm water, so there’s no oily remover and less rubbing. Merit Clean Lash and Clean Volume, Clinique Lash Power, Thrive Liquid Lash Extensions and Blinc are all tubing mascaras.

What is a good cheap mascara for sensitive eyes?

No7 Define & Enhance at Boots is listed as suitable for sensitive eyes and washes off with warm water. In the US, Almay Thickening is ophthalmologist tested and under $10.

Is hypoallergenic mascara better for sensitive eyes?

Not automatically. The US FDA says there are no federal standards for the word hypoallergenic on cosmetics, so it doesn’t promise anything on its own. I go by how a mascara comes off and whether it’s listed for sensitive eyes.

Is Kosas Soulgazer good for sensitive eyes?

Space NK and Sephora UK both list it as safe for sensitive eyes, and it’s the mascara I use most with ocular rosacea. It has a lash peptide, myristoyl pentapeptide-17, and comes in black and brown.

Does ILIA Limitless Lash come off with water?

Yes. Space NK says it removes with just warm water and doesn’t need makeup remover.

Is Clinique mascara good for sensitive eyes?

LOOKFANTASTIC lists Clinique Lash Power as ophthalmologist tested and fragrance free, and High Impact is sold as safe for sensitive eyes. Skip the fibre-infused High Impact High-Fi if fibres bother you.

Can you wear mascara with blepharitis?

I have blepharitis and I wear my four. Eyes are personal though, so if yours are flaring, ask your optician or eye doctor first.

Affiliate links, I earn commission if you buy through them.


Get my newsletter

One email every Friday with my latest posts and current discount codes. Free, and you can unsubscribe any time.

Google will show you more of my posts when you search, AI answers included. One tap, and you can undo it any time.

Follow:
Share:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Impact-Site-Verification: d2545ad9-002d-4ffb-963d-2499361a5052

Don't miss a thing

Get new posts straight to your inbox. No spam, I promise, I barely have time to email myself.

By signing up you agree to my privacy policy. Unsubscribe whenever, no hard feelings.

Thanks, you're in! Go check your inbox to confirm.